The Milk Myth

credit: kevinspencer
Cow's milk has been touted as being a great source of calcium and vitamin D, which are vital for healthy bones. However, the propaganda promoting milk and strong bones has become so ingrained in our culture that we believe if we do not drink milk, then our bones will deteriorate into nothing and we will turn into a massive heap of blood, muscle and guts.
The propaganda that we are feed, on a daily basis, covers up the truths behind what milk really is and has vastly exaggerated the benefits that are associated with dairy consumption.
We do not need to drink milk or eat any dairy products. We can obtain all of the so called benefits of drinking milk from countless other sources. Plus, the idea of drinking another animals lactating fluid is repulsive.
The Problem
Did you know that 60% of the world's population is lactose-intolerant? And that the majority of those people live in non-industrialized countries? Or that all human beings, when first born, are intolerant to cow's milk? or any other mammal's milk for that matter.
Webster defines milk as "a white fluid that is rich in fat and protein, secreted by female mammals for the nourishment of their young." The key word being YOUNG. When mammals are first born we are dependent on the nutrients that our mothers milk provides, without them we would die.
However, once the time passes when mother's milk is required for life, mammals no longer need it.
We never see a grown cow suckling on the tits of a mother cat.
Human beings are the only mammals on planet earth that drink the lactating milk of other animals.
I find it funny that the drinking of other mammals milk is culturally accepted, yet the drinking of our own species milk past the age of 2 or 3 is shunned upon, even th0ugh it is quite possibly the most nutritious substance known to man.
"New" Milk Production
In our modern societies battle to rid the world of all fat and cholesterol known to man, we have created what could be the most despicable creation in human history. Skim Milk.
The shit is gross. Having drunken it for twenty years of my life I only knew it as "better" for me than whole milk, yet had the consistency and taste of water. Since taking milk out of my diet I have slowly grown a repulsive appetite for skim milk.
The process in-which skim milk (and 1 or 2% milk as well) goes through is utterly (lol) moronic. We take the fat out of the milk, heat it to super high temperatures (called pasteurization, I used to think this meant that the cows were raised in a pasture) and then bottled and served to you with a happy cow sticker on the jug.
Our current societies war on fat has resulted in our milk products containing zero fat or cholesterol. The result of such a switch is the increase of sugar levels in these products.
When fat is taken out of products, the result is bland nothingness. Much like what fat free ranch dressing and fat free cheese taste like. To make up for the cardboard taste of fat free foods, sugar is added to make them more appetizing.
Next time you buy milk look at the sugar and carbohydrate levels of whole and skim milk, they are drastically different.
Calcium!
The cats meow of milk consumption. When all is said and done, we have to drink milk because we need calcium and milk has it! I'm sorry to burst the strong bones and calcium bubble, but as shocking as it may seem, calcium is not found only in milk.
Calcium is a mineral found in soil. When plants grow (grass, alfalfa and what ever is in a cow pasture) they absorb nutrients in the soil as they grow. Calcium is one of these nutrients and is therefore found in the plants that cows eat. Cows eat the plants. The calcium and other nutrients that were found in the plant material wind up in cows meat and if they are pregnant, in their utters via lactating glands found in the body.
The calcium found in dairy products actually comes from plants in the ground.
How do you think cows and all other mammals are able to maintain bone strength without drinking another species milk?
Calcium or Exercise?
A study was done on groups of women (over the age of 50) in the US that tested calcium supplement, exercise and bone health. The women were split into 5 groups. One group did nothing, they did not exercise or take a calcium supplement. Another group took a calcium supplement and did not exercise, the other took a calcium supplement and exercised, the other exercised and did not take a supplement.
The results were profound. The groups of women with the strongest bones after 6 months were the groups that exercised. And further, the group that took no supplements but exercised had equal bone strength as the group who took the supplement and exercised.
This clearly shows the exercise can drastically improve bone health without the aide of dietary calcium.
What about vitamin D?
Milk contains some vitamin D, but almost all milk for sale in a grocery store is fortified with it. Which simply means that they put the same vitamin D that is found in a multivitamin or supplement in milk. You can get these products for far cheaper than milk at Walgreens or any other pharmaceutical outlet without having to keep it refrigerated and worry over it spoiling.
Ryan, you are crazy, if milk is so bad then why are we told to drink it?
Remember my mantra: You are the only person who cares about your health, nobody else gives a shit. The nobody else in that statement includes your doctor, Oprah, The Doctors show before Oprah, your local news and anybody else other than me and your immediate family
.
The milk industry is only after your money. They use the supposed health benefits of milk to market their product so that we, the consumers, will buy it. In all honesty, the milk industry has done a phenomenal job in doing this. They have weaseled their way into the government recommended Food Pyramid and have now become a staple in our nations school lunch programs and our household refrigerators.
Yes milk contains calcium and calcium is a nutrient found in bones. Which is why milk is promoted as being the key to strong bones. In fact dark vegetables, meat and eggs also contain calcium at levels that are comparable, if not higher, to dairy products.
Final Thoughts
If what I have said above is not convincing enough for you to drop milk from your diet, then consider this:
For all you mothers out there, you know what it is like being pregnant. It freaking sucks (I do not know from personal experience, just observing). Imagine being pregnant every day of your life. When you have an infant, it is immediately taken away from you so that it can be butchered and sold as veil (calf meat). You then have your tits sucked on by a huge metal machine every morning and night for the rest of your life*. Welcome to the life of a modern day dairy cow.
* Until you can no longer produce milk. Then you will be purchased by McDonald's and turned into burger meat.
![]()
Milk less since 2009 and still alive and kicking,
-Ryan
May 7th, 2010 - 12:58
Ryan,
Do you purposely not drink milk ever now?
May 7th, 2010 - 14:22
Vanessa,
“Do you purposely not drink milk ever now?”
Yes, I no longer drink milk or consume any dairy products other than the occasional cheese binge. Living in Wisconsin and not drinking milk is like being and American and not eating McDonalds, I know. But you would actually be surprised how many people do not drink milk. I know many people who hate the taste of milk but drink it anyway because they are told to. When I give them the condensed version of my article, they are always floored and relieved!
I do not avoid milk like the plague by any means. I just never knowingly purchase any dairy products. Cottage cheese is gross, yogurt contains as much sugar as a candy bar and simply knowing what milk is repulses me. Cheese is the only dairy product that I actually enjoy
Do you drink milk?
Thanks for the comment Vanessa
Ryan
May 8th, 2010 - 12:45
Ryan, I remember last year when I cramped up in football and Lindert told me to start drinkin whole milk. I think you did too for a period to try and gain weight. That shit is like drinking paste. I can’t believe I drank that for like 4 months. I’m not even sure if it worked haha
May 10th, 2010 - 07:25
Patty
The stuff is pretty thick! Tastes a lot better than skim milk though. I wish I knew why whole milk is supposed to help with cramps….
Thanks for the comment Pat
Ryan
May 12th, 2010 - 19:51
Hey Ry!
Nice article dude. I have a question…if I start to drink less milk, what should i consume more of so that I still get calcium?
May 12th, 2010 - 19:53
Also, if you are already a skinny person with high metabolism would you want to cut milk out of your diet?
May 13th, 2010 - 07:52
Ky,
If are going to eliminate milk from your diet you should be consuming lots of whole foods. By that I mean that you should be eating foods that have not been processed or chemically altered in anyway. Fresh fruits, veggies, eggs, meat, nuts (lol) are examples. Truthfully these foods should be the basis of your diet anyway. Moving out of the dorms and living on your own will give you the opportunity to buy and eat foods that you want, without having to rely on what the campus cafeteria is serving.
Also, the amounts of calcium that we need are over exaggerated. Exercise and vitamin D do more for bone health than increased levels of calcium. Just look at your grandma, I know that she doesn’t drink milk and you don’t see her whittling away to nothing!
Thanks for reading and commenting Ky
Ryan
May 13th, 2010 - 07:57
Ky,
Being a skinny person with a high metabolism does not matter. Milk is not a magical substance that is needed to sustain life (other than when we are first born). Cutting milk out of your diet should have no harmful side affects, other than that you may be healthier. Dairy products are known to promote mucus creation in our bodies. So if you are coughing and hacking up lugies all day, then cutting out dairy might not be a bad idea.
I am a skinny guy as well, and I did not notice any ill effects of cutting out milk from my diet. I honestly did not notice any changes what so ever, other than the fact that I have a grown a repulsive appetite for milk.
You will be fine. No matter what the commercials and billboards tell you, you will not die by not drinking milk.
Ryan